Showing posts with label absence of evidence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label absence of evidence. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

Absence of Evidence - The Atheist Copout


It still galls me that atheists require perfect evidence to believe in God, but will settle for a half-ass theory to believe in evolution.

From Richard Dawkins to Johnny A. Theist down the road, the catchcry is "There is no evidence for God". When asked exactly what type of evidence they require in order to believe, of course they would not settle for anything less than perfect evidence, the type of peer-reviewed evidence demanded by science. But, there are way too many problems with this, including that peers can only review based on their current level of knowledge and understanding. Given a few more decades, chances are that the same peers would review somewhat differently. So, pardon the irony, but science is not an exact science.

A relevant question would be: What kind of evidence would it take to go from being an atheist to, let's say, an agnostic or simply one who shuts up and reserves judgement until clearer evidence is produced? The Catholic Church abounds with such evidence. It will never be scientifically peer-reviewed because science does not yet have to tools to deal with anything supernatural. And if a scientist believed some of this evidence, chances are they wouldn't want their peers to know about it.

A dog has more sensory perception than man, but we have to accept that the tools of science are wielded by mere men. It may take centuries before science can seriously study supernatural phenomena.

So, what evidence can we gather from the Catholic Church that supports the existence of God. The question is: where to begin? Here are a few starters:


  1. Incorrupt bodies of saints (the genuine ones, yes we know there have been hoaxes)

  2. Stigmata (again, the genuine ones), e.g. Padre Pio

  3. Marian apparitions - e.g. Medjugorje, where seers still see the Blessed Virgin Mary today and which has been studied by three teams of scientists since 1981

  4. Eucharistic Miracles - there have been too many to count and YouTube even has videos of them.

  5. Sun miracles, e.g. at Fatima and Medjugorje
  6. Other empirical and completely mind-boggling evidence, such as the image of Our Lady in a rock at Las Lajas, Colombia. Scientists drilled that rock and found the image to be coloured in the rock itself to a depth of several feet!

I've tried to include modern examples such as Medjugorje, which are subject to even greater and knowledgable scrutiny than those of past eras. I could have included the Fatima miracle, during which 70,000 people simultaneously witnessed an awesome solar display, but the older something is, unfortunately the more easy it is to dismiss.
I fear the problem with atheism is that its participants are generally a dishonest bunch, willing to find anything to absolve them from the necessity of studying these evidences. If they studied the scientific reports on the visionaries at Medjugorje as much as they studied their "Popular Science" magazine, there would no longer be any sensible reason to be an atheist. In fact, you'd be a fool to still call yourself an atheist.

Click here for information on the scientific investigations carried out on the Medjugorje visionaries.

Share This